Some candies disappear forever, some come back under a new owner, and some only lose a flavor, size, or package format. This Candy Graveyard tracks discontinued, hard-to-find, revived, seasonal, and replacement-worthy sweets.
Looking for something close? Each listing includes Blooms Candy product links only when there is a confirmed product page. Other alternatives are left as plain text so customers are not sent to empty searches.
10:30 candy bar
10:30 candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found in review. Need flavor confirmation for better matching.
Try instead: 100 Grand, Baby Ruth, Snickers, Goo Goo Cluster
Adams Sour gums
Adams Sour gums is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Original Adams sour gum line appears to be gone; use sour gum/candy alternatives.
Try instead: Bubble Jug, Toxic Waste Gum, Warheads Sour Gum, Cry Baby Gum
Altoids Gum
Altoids Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Altoids gum is not part of the current Altoids focus; current alternatives are mint gums rather than the original format.
Try instead: Ice Breakers Ice Cubes, Mentos Gum, Pur Gum, Dentyne Ice
Altoids Ginger
Altoids Ginger is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific Altoids Ginger flavor appears discontinued; ginger candy alternatives exist.
Try instead: Gin Gins, Claey's Ginger, Ginger Chews, Altoids Peppermint for tin nostalgia
Altoids Licorice
Altoids Licorice is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific Altoids Licorice flavor appears discontinued; use licorice/anise mints or gum.
Try instead: Black Jack Gum, C. Howard Scented Gum, Good & Plenty, licorice pastilles
Altoids Chocolate Mint
Altoids Chocolate Mint is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific Altoids Chocolate Mint flavor appears discontinued; chocolate-mint options still exist.
Try instead: Junior Mints, Andes Mints, York Peppermint Pattie, Frango-style mints
BB Bats — Discontinued 12/2020
BB Bats is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
BB Bats taffy suckers appear discontinued/very limited. Distributor confirmation recommended before stating permanent.
Try instead: Bonomo Turkish Taffy, Laffy Taffy, Airheads, Charms Blow Pop
Big Mouth Bubble Gum
Big Mouth Bubble Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
No current mainstream production found; match by novelty/bubble gum format.
Try instead: Big League Chew, Bubble Tape, Bubble Jug, Bazooka
Big Time
Big Time is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical item; insufficient verified flavor profile in quick review.
Try instead: Use customer memory to match: taffy, gum, chocolate bar, or hard candy alternatives
Bit-O-Licorice
Bit-O-Licorice is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Appears discontinued; match by licorice/anise chew profile.
Try instead: Good & Plenty, Black Jack Gum, Gustaf's licorice, C. Howard Scented Gum
Beech-Nut Spearmint and Wintergreen Gum
Beech-Nut Spearmint and Wintergreen Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Beech-Nut gum is historical/discontinued; match with vintage gum alternatives.
Try instead: Beemans, Teaberry, Black Jack, Clove, Dentyne Ice
Ben Hurs — similar to Sen Sen
Ben Hurs is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Ben Hur/Sen-Sen style licorice breath candy is essentially gone; alternatives are adjacent rather than exact.
Try instead: C. Howard Scented Gum, Sen-Sen-style licorice mints if found, Black Jack Gum, licorice pastilles
Big Buddy Bubble Gum
Big Buddy Bubble Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
No current mainstream production found; match by oversized novelty gum.
Try instead: Bubble Tape, Big League Chew, Bazooka, Bubble Jug
Big Mouth Suckers
Big Mouth Suckers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
No current mass-market version identified; match by oversized novelty sucker.
Try instead: Charms Blow Pops, Chupa Chups, Astro Pop, giant lollipops
Black Cat Bubble Gum
Black Cat Bubble Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
No current mainstream production found; match black/licorice gum or Halloween novelty angle.
Try instead: Black Jack Gum, Halloween gumballs, licorice gum, Bubble Jug
Black Licorice Dollars
Black Licorice Dollars is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific dollar-shape format appears gone; many licorice alternatives exist.
Try instead: Gustaf's licorice coins, licorice wheels, Australian soft licorice, Good & Plenty
Brock's Candy Puffs
Brock's Candy Puffs is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Original Brock's puffs are gone; soft peppermint puffs/candy puffs remain the closest eating experience.
Try instead: Brach's/Bob's Sweet Stripes soft peppermint, soft butter mints, dinner mints
Brach's Royals
Brach's Royals is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Brach's Milk Maid Royals are widely reported as discontinued; Brach's still sells Milk Maid caramels but not Royals.
Try instead: Brach's Milk Maid Caramels, Werther's Soft Caramels, Cow Tales, Lancaster Caramels
Bub's Daddy bubble gum ropes
Bub's Daddy bubble gum ropes is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific gum rope appears discontinued; match rope/tape gum.
Try instead: Bubble Tape, Hubba Bubba Tape, Big League Chew, Bubble Jug
Butternut candy bar
Butternut candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Hollywood Butter-Nut/Butternut bar appears discontinued; profile is chocolatey-covered caramel and peanuts.
Try instead: Goo Goo Cluster, Baby Ruth, Oh Henry! Canada import, Chocolatey PayDay
Candy Lipsticks — gold paper/cellophane, bright red, rubbed off on lips
Candy Lipsticks is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Old edible lipstick candy format appears gone in its original form; novelty lipstick candies exist but may differ.
Try instead: Wax lips, candy lipstick novelties, Nik-L-Nip wax bottles, novelty candy makeup
Caravelle
Caravelle is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: 100 Grand, Milky Way, Charleston Chew, Goo Goo Cluster
Cherry Hump
Cherry Hump is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical cherry/coconut/chocolate-style item; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Cherry Mash, Cherry Cordials, Mallo Cup, Idaho Spud
Chicken Dinner candy bar
Chicken Dinner candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical Sperry candy bar; no current production.
Try instead: PayDay, Pearson's Salted Nut Roll, Baby Ruth, Goo Goo Cluster
Choco'Lite
Choco'Lite is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Nestlé/Hershey-style aerated chocolate bar discontinued; modern aerated chocolate exists.
Try instead: Aero Bar, Cadbury Wispa import, 3 Musketeers, Milky Way
Chum Gum
Chum Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Classic gum discontinued; match by nostalgic bubble gum.
Try instead: Beemans, Teaberry, Bubble Tape, Bazooka
Clorets — Discontinued 2016
Clorets is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Clorets gum/mints are gone in the U.S.; chlorophyll-fresh breath alternatives exist.
Try instead: Choward's mints, Altoids, Tic Tac, chlorophyll mints/gum
Denver Sandwich Bar
Denver Sandwich Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Clark Bar, Butterfinger, 5th Avenue, Zagnut
Dentyne Classic Gum
Dentyne Classic Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Original classic Dentyne stick gum appears gone; modern Dentyne Ice format differs.
Try instead: Dentyne Ice, Beemans, Black Jack, Clove, Teaberry
Dominos Pizza Gum
Dominos Pizza Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Novelty pizza gum appears discontinued.
Try instead: Pizza gummy/candy novelty, Bubble Jug, novelty food-shaped gummies
Dynamints
Dynamints is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Classic tiny mints discontinued/hard to find.
Try instead: Tic Tac, Ice Breakers, Altoids Smalls, Certs-style mints
Dinosaur Eggs — Wonka egg-shaped jawbreakers
Dinosaur Eggs is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Wonka Dinosaur Eggs format appears gone; current Wonka site signals future/coming soon but not this product.
Try instead: Jaw Busters, Jawbreakers, Everlasting Gobstopper, Cry Baby Tears
Dr. Pepper Gum — Discontinued 2017
Dr. Pepper Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific licensed gum discontinued; match with soda-flavored candy/gum.
Try instead: Dr Pepper Jelly Belly, Dr Pepper cotton candy, soda-flavored gummies, Bottle Caps
Dr. Pepper Licorice — Discontinued 2020
Dr. Pepper Licorice is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific licensed licorice discontinued; match with soda-flavored candies.
Try instead: Dr Pepper Jelly Belly, Dr Pepper cotton candy, Bottle Caps, cola gummies
Fan Tan gum
Fan Tan gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical gum; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Beemans, Teaberry, Black Jack, Clove
Fizzers — Discontinued 2019
Fizzers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Smarties-style Fizzers appear gone in U.S.; use fizzy/sherbet alternatives.
Try instead: Smarties, Rockets, Zotz, Fizzies drink tablets if available
Fizzies
Fizzies is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Classic drink tablets have come and gone; current availability is inconsistent.
Try instead: Zotz, effervescent drink tablets, Pop Rocks, retro soda powder candy
Forever Yours
Forever Yours is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Mars Forever Yours was a predecessor/similar to Milky Way Midnight; original name discontinued.
Try instead: Milky Way Midnight, 3 Musketeers, vanilla nougat chocolate bars
Fortune Bubble Gum — Produced from 2016-2019
Fortune Bubble Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Novelty gum format appears discontinued.
Try instead: Bazooka with comics, fortune cookies, Bubble Tape, Bubble Jug
Freshen Up Peppermint — March 2015
Freshen Up Peppermint is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Freshen Up liquid-center gum discontinued; no exact current U.S. replacement.
Try instead: Trident Splash, Mentos Pure Fresh, Ice Breakers Ice Cubes, Dentyne Ice
Freshen Up Spearmint — March 2015
Freshen Up Spearmint is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Freshen Up liquid-center gum discontinued; no exact current U.S. replacement.
Try instead: Trident Splash, Mentos Pure Fresh, Ice Breakers Ice Cubes, Dentyne Ice
Fruit Stripe Gum — January 2024
Fruit Stripe Gum has been discontinued; any remaining packs are leftover stock.
Ferrara confirmed Fruit Stripe and Super Bubble gum production ended; remaining stock may appear only as leftover/resale.
Try instead: Fruit Stripe gummies if found, Big League Chew, Bubble Tape, Bubble Jug, fruity gumballs
Gatorade Gum
Gatorade Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Licensed sports-drink gum discontinued.
Try instead: Gatorade chews, electrolyte gummies, fruit gum, Sour Patch Kids Energy-style candy if available
High Noon candy bar
High Noon candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: PayDay, Baby Ruth, Goo Goo Cluster, Salted Nut Roll
Hollywood candy bar
Hollywood candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Hollywood Candy Company bar line is defunct; only descendants like PayDay/Zero survived under other owners.
Try instead: PayDay, Zero Bar, Baby Ruth, Goo Goo Cluster
Ice Cream gum
Ice Cream gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific novelty ice-cream-flavored gum appears gone.
Try instead: Cotton candy/ice cream gumballs, Bubble Yum, Hubba Bubba, novelty dessert gum
KITTS Taffy — Discontinued 12/2020
KITTS Taffy is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Kitts taffy appears discontinued; use wrapped taffy alternatives.
Try instead: Laffy Taffy, Airheads, Now and Later, Salt Water Taffy
Lifesaver Swirl Pops
Lifesaver Swirl Pops is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific lollipop format appears discontinued; Life Savers brand continues.
Try instead: Life Savers hard candy, Charms Blow Pops, Chupa Chups, Dum Dums
Lunch Bar
Lunch Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream U.S. production found. Note: Cadbury Lunch Bar exists internationally and may confuse searches.
Try instead: Kit Kat, Take 5, Crunch bars, imported Cadbury Lunch Bar if desired
Marathon Bar — see Curly Wurly
The original Marathon Bar is discontinued; Curly Wurly is the closest modern replacement.
Original Mars Marathon is discontinued; Cadbury Curly Wurly is the closest modern shape/texture alternative.
Try instead: Curly Wurly, 100 Grand, Milk Duds, Riesen
Merri Mints
Merri Mints is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Classic multicolor meltaway mints discontinued/hard to source.
Try instead: Richardson Butter Mints, pastel dinner mints, butter mints, Brach's mints
Milkshake candy bar
Milkshake candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Hollywood Milkshake candy bar discontinued; no exact modern match.
Try instead: Milky Way, 3 Musketeers, Charleston Chew, Mars Bar import
Mint Juleps — Discontinued 2018
Mint Juleps is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Mint Juleps candy appears discontinued; match mint chew flavor.
Try instead: Brach's Milk Maid Caramels, mint taffy, butter mints, Andes Mints
My Buddy Candy Bar
My Buddy Candy Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Baby Ruth, Oh Henry! Canada import, Snickers, Goo Goo Cluster
Oompahs — new ones by Willy Wonka are not the same
Oompahs is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Original Oompahs format/flavor gone; current Wonka brand is not a direct replacement.
Try instead: Peanut butter M&M's, Reese's Pieces, Sixlets, candy-coated peanut butter bites
Orange-Its, Grape-Its and Cherry-Its
Orange-Its, Grape-Its and Cherry-Its is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
These fruit-flavored hard candy boxes appear discontinued.
Try instead: Lemonhead family flavors if available, Runts, Chewy Spree, Bottle Caps, Mike and Ike
Pal Bubble Gum
Pal Bubble Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical gum; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Bazooka, Dubble Bubble, Beemans, Teaberry
PBMax candy bar
PBMax candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Mars PB Max remains discontinued; no exact cookie/peanut butter/chocolate bar match.
Try instead: Reese's Sticks, Nutty Buddy, Butterfinger, 5th Avenue, Take 5
Pepsin gum
Pepsin gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical digestive gum; no current mainstream equivalent.
Try instead: Beemans, Black Jack, Clove, ginger chews
Pom Poms
Pom Poms is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Raisinets, Goobers, chocolate-covered peanuts/raisins, bridge mix
Powerhouse candy bar
Powerhouse candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Peter Paul Powerhouse bar discontinued.
Try instead: Baby Ruth, PayDay, Snickers, Pearson's Salted Nut Roll
Prairie Schooner
Prairie Schooner is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: PayDay, Salted Nut Roll, Goo Goo Cluster, Baby Ruth
Saf T Pops — DISC 1/2022
Saf T Pops is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Saf-T-Pops appear discontinued; Spangler/Dum Dums are the practical safety/lollipop substitute.
Try instead: Dum Dums, Charms Mini Pops, flat lollipops, toddler-safe lollipop alternatives
Screaming Yellow Zonkers
Screaming Yellow Zonkers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Glazed popcorn snack discontinued; match by sweet popcorn/caramel corn.
Try instead: Cracker Jack, Fiddle Faddle, Poppycock, caramel corn
Seven-Up candy bar
Seven-Up candy bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Vintage 7 Up/Seven-Up candy bar discontinued; no exact seven-section bar remains.
Try instead: Sky Bar, Valomilk, Goo Goo Cluster, assorted chocolate box
Snirkles
Snirkles is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Snickers, Baby Ruth, Goo Goo Cluster, Oh Henry! Canada import
Squirrel Nut Chocolate Caramels
Squirrel Nut Chocolate Caramels is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific chocolate caramel format appears discontinued; match caramel/nut chew profile.
Try instead: Squirrel Nut Zippers if available, Sugar Babies, Milk Duds, Cow Tales, Riesen
Squirrel Nut Zippers
Squirrel Nut Zippers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Classic nut caramel chew appears discontinued/hard to find.
Try instead: Sugar Babies, Milk Duds, Riesen, Bit-O-Honey, Cow Tales
Sugar Mama
Sugar Mama is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Chocolate-covered Sugar Daddy/Sugar Babies style candy appears discontinued.
Try instead: Sugar Daddy, Sugar Babies, Milk Duds, Cow Tales, Black Cow Bars
Super Bubble — Disc 2022
Super Bubble has been discontinued; any remaining packs are leftover stock.
Ferrara confirmed Super Bubble and Fruit Stripe gum production ended; remaining stock may appear only as leftover/resale.
Try instead: Dubble Bubble, Bazooka, Big League Chew, Bubble Tape, Bubble Jug
Summit Bar
Summit Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Mars Summit bar discontinued; match chocolate/peanut/wafer/crunchy profile.
Try instead: Whatchamacallit, 100 Grand, Take 5, Nutty Buddy
SweetTart Roll Sour Chewy Extreme
SweetTart Roll Sour Chewy Extreme is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
SweeTARTS Extreme Sour Chewy has been difficult to find and appears discontinued/unavailable in common retail listings.
Try instead: Chewy Spree, Sour Skittles, Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour, Sour Patch Kids, Bottle Caps
Waleco Coconut Bar
Waleco Coconut Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific coconut bar appears discontinued; match coconut/chocolate bar profile.
Try instead: Mounds, Almond Joy, Bounty import, coconut Long Boys
Walnettos
Walnettos is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Walnettos chewy walnut caramel candy appears discontinued/hard to find.
Try instead: Sugar Babies, Milk Duds, Riesen, Cow Tales, walnut caramels
Walnut Crush
Walnut Crush is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Bun Bar Maple, Pearson's Nut Goodie, Goo Goo Cluster, Baby Ruth
Whistle Pops — 2015-2021; DISC 1/2021
Whistle Pops is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Modern Whistle Pops revival appears discontinued; other novelty lollipops exist.
Try instead: Ring Pop, Melody Pops if imported, Charms Blow Pop, novelty sound lollipops
Whiz Bar
Whiz Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Historical candy bar; no current mainstream production found.
Try instead: Charleston Chew, 3 Musketeers, Milky Way, Zero Bar
Altoids Sours — Back in 2024 - RETRO SOURS
Original Altoids Sours are discontinued, but Retro Sours are the closest modern replacement.
Original Altoids Sours are not back under the Altoids brand; Retro Sours are a modern revival-style replacement from Iconic Candy.
Try instead: Retro Sours, Warheads, Toxic Waste, Sour Patch Kids
Banana Splits — Back in Stock!
Banana Splits is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Page says back in stock; keep as a graveyard/revival entry rather than simply discontinued.
Try instead: Banana Splits, Banana Laffy Taffy, Runts banana, Banana Now and Later
Bar None by Hershey — IN STOCK NOW! 8/2019
Original Hershey BarNone was discontinued, but a revived BarNone exists; availability can be intermittent.
Original Hershey BarNone was discontinued; Iconic Candy revived BarNone. Iconic's current collection showed the item as sold out in recent search results, so phrase as available/intermittent.
Try instead: BarNone when available, Kinder Bueno, Kit Kat, Whatchamacallit, Nutty Buddy
Beemans Gum — IN STOCK NOW!
Beemans Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Gerrit J. Verburg lists Beemans among its vintage gum products.
Try instead: Beemans, Teaberry, Black Jack, Clove
Black Jack Gum — IN STOCK NOW!
Black Jack Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Gerrit J. Verburg lists Black Jack Gum as current in its vintage gum portfolio.
Try instead: Black Jack Gum, Beemans, Clove, Teaberry
Bonkers — try Hi-Chew
Bonkers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Leaf Brands lists Bonkers! as a revived product; availability may be uneven by distributor.
Try instead: Bonkers when available, Hi-Chew, Mamba, Starburst, Now and Later
Bonkers Fruit Chews — Estimated Return End of 2025
Bonkers Fruit Chews is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Leaf Brands lists Bonkers! as a current/revived brand, but distributor availability should be checked before promising dates.
Try instead: Bonkers when available, Hi-Chew, Mamba, Starburst
Bubble Jug — Back - slightly different
Bubble Jug is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Iconic Candy currently lists Bubble Jug flavors in stock; modern version may differ.
Try instead: Bubble Jug, Bubble Tape, Big League Chew, Pop Rocks + gum novelty set
Chiclets Tiny Fruit — Back in Stock March 2022
Chiclets Tiny Fruit is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Page says back in stock; verify distributor before promising ongoing availability.
Try instead: Chiclets Tiny Fruit, MiniMini Chicle Gum, Dubble Bubble chiclets, gumballs
Clove Gum — IN STOCK
Clove Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Gerrit J. Verburg lists Clove Gum as current in its vintage gum portfolio.
Try instead: Clove Gum, Black Jack, Beemans, Teaberry
Reed's Candy Rolls — Back in stock Fall 2015!!
Reed's Candy Rolls is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Iconic Candy lists Reed's hard candy products as part of its revived portfolio.
Try instead: Reed's rolls, Claey's, Life Savers, Regal Crown
Regal Crown Sours — Back in stock!
Regal Crown Sours is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Iconic Candy lists Regal Crown products including sour flavors.
Try instead: Regal Crown Sours, Retro Sours, Warheads, Claey's sour drops
Reggie Bar — Back in stock! 2023
Reggie Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Page says back in stock; verify current supplier availability before promising.
Try instead: Reggie Bar when available, Baby Ruth, Bun Bar, Snickers
Sky Bar — Back in Stock
Sky Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Sky Bar was revived after NECCO; Sky Bar Confectionary sells current Sky Bars.
Try instead: Sky Bar, Valomilk, Goo Goo Cluster, assorted-filled chocolates
TeaBerry Gum — Back in stock 2020
TeaBerry Gum is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Gerrit J. Verburg lists Teaberry Flavored Gum and sugar-free Teaberry as current.
Try instead: Teaberry Gum, Beemans, Black Jack, Clove
Toxic Waste Slime Lickers — Late 2023 - Back in 2024
Toxic Waste Slime Lickers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Page says back in 2024; keep for SEO but avoid implying current discontinuation.
Try instead: Toxic Waste Slime Licker, Warheads spray, Sour liquid candy, Sour Punch
Tart-n-Tiny — Back in stock!
Tart-n-Tiny is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Leaf Brands lists tart n' tinys among its current/revived products.
Try instead: Tart-n-Tiny, Nerds, Runts, Sweetarts Mini Chewy, Bottle Caps
Wacky Wafers — Back in Stock!
Wacky Wafers is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Leaf Brands describes Wacky Wafers as brought back; availability may fluctuate.
Try instead: Wacky Wafers, Smarties candy wafers, Bottle Caps, SweeTARTS
Bit-O-Honey Bar — Singles still available
The old Bit-O-Honey bar format is gone, but Bit-O-Honey pieces are still made.
The old bar format is the issue; Bit-O-Honey candy pieces remain current under Spangler.
Try instead: Bit-O-Honey pieces, Mary Jane-style peanut butter kisses, Peanut Chews
Big League Chew Cotton Candy
Big League Chew Cotton Candy is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Big League Chew brand continues, but Cotton Candy flavor appears to be the discontinued item.
Try instead: Big League Chew Original, cotton candy bubble gum, Bubble Yum Cotton Candy, Hubba Bubba
Black Cow sucker — Try Black Cow Bars
Black Cow sucker is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
The sucker/lollipop format is discontinued; Black Cow-style bars are the suggested replacement.
Try instead: Black Cow Bars, Sugar Daddy, Cow Tales Caramel, Sugar Babies
Chewy Gobstoppers
Chewy Gobstoppers appear gone, but regular Everlasting Gobstoppers are still made.
Regular Everlasting Gobstopper is current, but Chewy Gobstoppers appear to be the discontinued SKU.
Try instead: Everlasting Gobstopper, Chewy Spree, Runts, Bottle Caps
Chewy Lemonheads — 2024
Chewy Lemonheads is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Chewy Lemonhead Fruit Mix appears discontinued/hard to find, while Lemonhead brand continues with original and new ropes.
Try instead: Lemonhead Ropes, Lemonheads, Chewy Spree, Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour
Cow Tales Chocolate — Try Cow Tales Caramel Brownie
Cow Tales Chocolate is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Original chocolate Cow Tales naming/format has changed; Goetze lists Caramel Brownie Cow Tales as current.
Try instead: Cow Tales Caramel Brownie, Cow Tales Caramel, Sugar Daddy, Black Cow Bars
Giant Pixy Stick — Now Half Size
Giant Pixy Stick is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Pixy Stix brand continues but the giant size appears reduced/discontinued.
Try instead: Pixy Stix, Fun Dip, Giant candy straws, Sour Punch Straws
Laffy Taffy Strawberry — Discontinued 2022
Strawberry Laffy Taffy still appears in current Laffy Taffy products; specify the discontinued format/SKU.
Laffy Taffy brand still lists products and strawberry appears in current minis/assortments; likely a bulk bar/jar/SKU issue.
Try instead: Laffy Taffy Strawberry where available, Strawberry Airheads, Now and Later Strawberry, Starburst Strawberry
Lifesavers Clove, Tangerine, All Sour Flavors, Cinnamon, Cherry
Lifesavers Clove, Tangerine, All Sour Flavors, Cinnamon, Cherry is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific Life Savers flavors have disappeared, but Life Savers brand continues.
Try instead: Life Savers Five Flavor, Regal Crown Sours, Claey's hard candies, Cinnamon Discs, Cherry sours
Mary Janes, chocolate covered
Mary Janes, chocolate covered is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Chocolate-covered Mary Janes appear gone; Mary Jane/peanut butter molasses flavor can be approximated.
Try instead: Mary Jane-style peanut butter kisses, Bit-O-Honey, Peanut Chews, Clark cups
Mike & Ike Zours — See Sourlicious
Zours are gone, but Mike and Ike sour candies still exist under newer names.
Zours name is discontinued; Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour and other sour Mike and Ike products are current alternatives.
Try instead: Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour, Sourlicious if stocked, Sour Patch Kids, Skittles Sour
Mike & Ike Sourlicious Fruit Punch
Mike & Ike Sourlicious Fruit Punch is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Specific Sourlicious Fruit Punch appears hard to find/discontinued; Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour remains current.
Try instead: Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour, Mike and Ike Mega Mix, Sour Patch Kids, Skittles Sour
Slo-Poke Lollipops — See Slo Poke Bars
Slo-Poke Lollipops is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
The lollipop format is gone; Slo Poke bars are the appropriate replacement.
Try instead: Slo Poke Bars, Sugar Daddy, Cow Tales, Black Cow Bars
Tangy Taffy
Tangy Taffy is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Tangy Taffy name changed/evolved into Laffy Taffy; exact old branding is gone.
Try instead: Laffy Taffy Stretchy & Tangy, Airheads, Now and Later, salt water taffy
Warhead All Mixed Up Peg Bag
Warhead All Mixed Up Peg Bag is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Warheads brand continues, but this specific peg bag/assortment appears discontinued.
Try instead: Warheads Extreme Sour, Warheads Cubes, Toxic Waste, Sour Patch Kids
Brach's Jelly Nougats
The exact old Brach's jelly nougat format may be gone, but seasonal nougat candies still appear.
Brach's nougats appear mainly seasonal/current in some formats; the exact old square jelly nougat format may be discontinued.
Try instead: Brach's seasonal nougats, jelly nougats from specialty suppliers, Christmas Nougats Mix
Toffifay — DISC 1/2022 - Now Seasonal
Toffifay is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Storck currently has Toffifay brand information; page should say seasonal/limited distribution rather than fully discontinued.
Try instead: Toffifay when seasonal, Werther's caramels, Riesen, Ferrero Rocher, hazelnut chocolates
Wonka Bar — comes & goes
Wonka Bar is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Wonka candy branding comes and goes; current official Wonka site signals future products, but classic Wonka Bar availability is intermittent.
Try instead: Wonka Bar when available, Cadbury Dairy Milk, Hershey bars, novelty golden ticket chocolate bars
Oh! Henry — Discontinued 2019 - Returned 2022
Oh Henry is hard to find in the U.S., but Canadian Oh Henry products are current.
U.S. availability has been messy; Hershey Canada currently lists Oh Henry products.
Try instead: Oh Henry! Canada import, Baby Ruth, Snickers, Goo Goo Cluster, Chocolatey PayDay
Gobstoppers — 2024
Regular Gobstoppers are still current; check whether you mean Chewy Gobstoppers or a specific package.
Regular Everlasting Gobstopper is currently listed by Ferrara; likely issue is Chewy Gobstoppers or a specific pack/size.
Try instead: Everlasting Gobstopper, Jawbreakers, Runts, Bottle Caps
Lifesavers Wint-O-Green — 2023
Wint-O-Green mints are still current; specify the discontinued package if needed.
Life Savers Wint-O-Green mints are currently listed by Life Savers in bags and rolls; likely a specific package/format issue.
Try instead: Life Savers Wint-O-Green mints, wintergreen lozenges, Altoids Wintergreen, Ice Breakers Wintergreen
Pine Brothers Cough Drops — soft version of Smith Brothers
Pine Brothers Cough Drops is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Pine Brothers has had revivals; exact soft drop availability is channel-specific and should be distributor-checked before listing as dead.
Try instead: Smith Brothers, Luden's, C. Howard mints, soft cough drops
Punch
Punch is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Item name is too broad for reliable customer wording; needs brand/flavor/format detail.
Try instead: If fruit chew: Hi-Chew/Mamba/Starburst. If hard candy: Regal Crown/Claey's.
Sour Bites
Sour Bites is listed as discontinued or hard to find.
Name is broad; exact brand/form discontinued needs confirmation.
Try instead: Sour Patch Kids, Sour Punch Bites, Warheads, Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers
You can set the offer title and subtitle in your Upsell Offer!
Will it be candy? Will it be a weird gift? Will it be both? Only way to find out is to try your luck!
Items are selected randomly and will always be a value of $10 or greater in retail value.
